When IVF hasn’t worked, sometimes the most important next step is to look at things differently.
By Dr Kokum Jayasinghe | Fertility & IVF Specialist, Melbourne IVF
Introduction — Another Negative Result
You’ve done the injections, attended the scans, had the egg collection and waited for the pregnancy test.
Perhaps you had a beautiful embryo transferred. Everything seemed promising.
And then, another negative result.
For many patients who come to see me after unsuccessful IVF treatment, the question is the same:
“Why isn’t this working, and what can we do differently?”
It’s a question that deserves more than simply booking another cycle.
How Many Failed IVF Cycles Are Too Many?
There is no magic number.
Even a good-quality embryo doesn’t guarantee a pregnancy. And not every unsuccessful transfer means something has gone wrong.
The 2023 European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) recommendations on recurrent implantation failure emphasise that each patient’s individual chance of pregnancy matters more than an arbitrary number of failed transfers.
A woman in her early thirties who has transferred several good-quality embryos may need a very different approach from someone in her forties.
It’s not just how many times IVF hasn’t worked. It’s what we’ve learned along the way.
What Should We Look at Before Trying Again?
When I review previous IVF cycles, I want to understand the whole picture.
1. The Ovaries
Did the stimulation protocol give us the best reasonable response? Could we approach things differently next cycle?
2. The Eggs and Embryos
Were there problems with egg maturity, fertilisation or embryo development? How did the embryos behave in the laboratory?
3. The Uterus
Have we adequately assessed the uterine cavity, endometrium, progesterone exposure and transfer conditions? In selected cases, hysteroscopy or laparoscopy may be worth considering, particularly when conditions such as endometriosis or adenomyosis are suspected.
4. The Sperm
Is there a reason to investigate beyond a standard semen analysis?
5. The Treatment Itself
Were there opportunities to adjust the plan as the cycle progressed?
Sometimes we identify something worth changing. Sometimes the original treatment was entirely appropriate.
The important thing is knowing the difference.
Does More Treatment Mean Better Treatment?
Not necessarily.
After unsuccessful IVF, patients are often offered additional investigations and treatments, including immune therapies, endometrial receptivity testing, endometrial scratching and other IVF add-ons.
Some may have a role in selected circumstances, but many lack convincing evidence of improving live-birth rates.
The Evidence on Common IVF Add-Ons
A large randomised trial published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2019 found that endometrial scratching made no difference to live-birth rates: 26.1% in both groups.
The UK’s Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) also currently rates endometrial receptivity testing (ERA) as “red” — meaning that evidence from moderate-to-high quality studies suggests this add-on may actually reduce treatment effectiveness for most fertility patients.
Similarly, the American Society for Reproductive Medicine’s 2024 committee opinion concluded that routine PGT-A testing has not been demonstrated to benefit every IVF patient.
Doing What Makes a Difference
My approach is not to do more simply because we can. It’s to do what has a reasonable chance of making a difference.
Something Patients Don’t Always Ask — Who Is Actually Doing Your IVF Treatment?
When choosing a fertility specialist, most patients focus on success rates, experience and treatment options.
But there’s another question worth asking:
Will the specialist you choose be the doctor looking after you throughout your treatment?
Who performs your ultrasound scans? Who collects your eggs? Who transfers your embryo? And when something isn’t going to plan, who do you speak to?
Why Continuity of Care Matters
In my practice, I personally perform my patients’ monitoring scans, egg collections and embryo transfers.
That continuity is important to me.
IVF isn’t one decision made at the first consultation. It’s a series of decisions made as we learn more about your response, your eggs, your embryos and your individual circumstances.
I want to see those changes myself, discuss them with you and adjust our approach when there’s a good reason to do so.
I also want my patients to be able to ask me questions directly, rather than feel that every concern has to pass through someone else.
A Realistic Promise
Continuity of care doesn’t guarantee a pregnancy. No specialist can promise that.
But it gives us the opportunity to make decisions together, throughout the process, with a shared understanding of what we’re trying to achieve.
And whatever the outcome, I want my patients to feel confident that we made thoughtful decisions and gave their treatment our best effort.
Behind Every Embryo Is a Team Making Important Decisions
IVF doesn’t end with the egg collection. What happens in the laboratory is just as important.
Working With Melbourne IVF’s Scientific Team
I work closely with our experienced embryologists and scientific leadership team at Melbourne IVF, supported by a state-of-the-art laboratory with excellent pregnancy outcomes.
We discuss individual cases, review fertilisation and embryo development, and consider whether anything can be optimised in the laboratory — from fertilisation techniques and sperm selection to embryo culture and transfer planning.
The Right Technology Used the Right Way
It’s not simply about having access to advanced technology. It’s about knowing when, why and how to use it for each patient.
That collaboration between clinician and scientist, combined with continuity of care throughout treatment, is central to how I practise.
My patients aren’t simply following a standard IVF protocol. Their treatment is reviewed, discussed and refined as we learn more, with one goal: giving every embryo and every cycle the best possible chance.
When Should You Consider an IVF Second Opinion?
You don’t need to wait for a certain number of failed cycles.
Signs It May Be Time for a Fresh Review
Consider a second opinion if you have experienced:
- Repeated unsuccessful embryo transfers
- Poor ovarian response or low egg numbers
- Unexpected embryo development problems
- A known reproductive condition such as PCOS, endometriosis or adenomyosis
- Uncertainty about recommended add-ons or additional investigations
- A general feeling that your current plan is no longer working for you
A Second Opinion Isn’t a Criticism
Seeking a second opinion doesn’t mean your previous specialist was wrong.
Sometimes it reveals a different approach worth considering. Sometimes it confirms that continuing with the existing plan is reasonable.
Either way, you should understand why.
My Approach — A Plan That Evolves With You
I’ve cared for patients who have been through many unsuccessful IVF attempts. I know that by the time they come for another opinion, they may have lost confidence — not just in the treatment, but in whether they’ll ever achieve the family they’re hoping for.
What I Can Promise
I can’t promise to find every answer.
But I can promise to:
- Listen carefully to your story
- Review what has happened in previous cycles
- Explain the evidence clearly
- Work with you to decide what comes next
Lifestyle and dietary factors can also play a meaningful role, and I often discuss strategies around fertility diet and lifestyle and improving natural fertility where relevant.
More Than Another Attempt
Because successful fertility care isn’t simply about following a protocol. It’s about understanding the person, recognising what we’re learning and knowing when to change direction.
If IVF hasn’t worked, you deserve more than another attempt. You deserve a clear reason for your next step — and a specialist who takes that step with you.
Considering a Second Opinion After Unsuccessful IVF?
Dr Kokum Jayasinghe is a Melbourne fertility specialist providing individualised IVF care, including assessment of repeated IVF failure, poor ovarian response, implantation failure and complex fertility challenges.
Book a consultation to review your previous treatment and discuss your next steps.
👉 Book a Fertility Consultation
Scientific References
- ESHRE Working Group on Recurrent Implantation Failure. ESHRE good practice recommendations on recurrent implantation failure. Human Reproduction Open. 2023;2023(3). Read article.
- Lensen S, et al. A Randomized Trial of Endometrial Scratching before In Vitro Fertilization. New England Journal of Medicine. 2019;380:325–334. Read article.
- Practice Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. The use of preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy: a committee opinion. Fertility and Sterility. 2024. Read guidance.
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Endometrial receptivity testing. https://www.hfea.gov.uk/treatments/treatment-add-ons/endometrial-receptivity-testing/

















