One of the questions I am often asked in an IVF consultation is:

“Is a frozen embryo transfer better than a fresh transfer?”

My answer is usually: not necessarily.

And perhaps I am particularly qualified to sit on the fence on this one.

My two boys came from the same IVF stimulation cycle. One was born following a fresh embryo transfer. The other came later, from a frozen embryo from that same cycle.

I love them both dearly — and I wouldn’t have done it any other way.

That experience also reflects something I believe strongly in as a fertility specialist: there isn’t one embryo‑transfer strategy that is right for every woman.

The question should not simply be, “Is fresh or frozen better?”

A much better question is:

“Which approach is right for me, in this particular IVF cycle?”

What is the difference between fresh and frozen embryo transfer?

After an IVF egg collection, embryos are created and cultured in the laboratory.

Fresh embryo transfer 

An embryo is transferred into the uterus several days after the egg collection, during the same treatment cycle.

Frozen embryo transfer (FET)

suitable embryos are cryopreserved using vitrification and transferred in a later menstrual cycle.

Modern vitrification is an extraordinary technology and has transformed IVF. It allows us to:

  • safely store embryos
  • undertake genetic testing when appropriate
  • reduce the risk of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS)
  • plan embryo transfer for a later cycle when circumstances are more favourable

But the fact that we can freeze embryos very successfully does not mean that every embryo needs to be frozen.

Is frozen embryo transfer more successful than fresh?

For most ovulatory women, the evidence does not support a blanket statement that frozen transfer is better.

A large multicentre randomised trial of 2,157 ovulatory women published in the New England Journal of Medicine compared fresh embryo transfer with freezing embryos and transferring them later.

The live birth rates were essentially the same:

  • 50.2% following fresh transfer
  • 48.7% following frozen transfer

Another randomised trial comparing a freeze‑all strategy with fresh blastocyst transfer in women with regular menstrual cycles similarly found no significant improvement in live birth with routine freeze‑all.

Longer‑term follow‑up of that trial is particularly interesting. When researchers considered all subsequent frozen transfers from the original egg collection, cumulative live birth remained virtually identical:

  • 42.6% with freeze‑all
  • 41.7% with a fresh‑transfer strategy

But there was one important difference.

The median time to the first pregnancy was approximately 106 days after freeze‑all, compared with 29 days following the fresh‑transfer strategy.

That matters to patients.

Most women sitting in front of me would have preferred to be pregnant yesterday.

If there is no medical reason to delay embryo transfer, I don’t believe we should automatically make a patient wait another cycle simply because freezing is available.

When do I consider a fresh embryo transfer?

If a woman has responded appropriately to stimulation, has no significant risk of OHSS, her endometrium looks appropriate and there is no concerning premature progesterone rise, a fresh embryo transfer can be a perfectly reasonable option.

I don’t make that decision from a single blood‑test number.

I assess the whole cycle — including:

  • ovarian response
  • progesterone around the time of trigger
  • endometrial development
  • symptoms
  • embryo factors
  • the individual woman’s circumstances

This becomes particularly relevant in women with a lower ovarian response.

A patient may have only one embryo, sometimes of less‑than‑perfect morphology, and it may represent her only or last opportunity from that cycle. Provided the uterine and hormonal environment is appropriate, the potential benefits and disadvantages of transferring that embryo fresh deserve individual discussion rather than automatically applying a freeze‑all policy.

Recent evidence makes this particularly interesting.

A 2025 multicentre randomised trial published in The BMJ studied women considered to have a low prognosis for IVF treatment:

  • Live birth occurred in 40% of women assigned to fresh transfer, compared with 32% assigned to frozen transfer.
  • Cumulative live birth within one year was also higher with the fresh‑transfer strategy: 51% versus 44%.

This doesn’t mean every poor responder should have a fresh transfer.

It does mean we should be careful about assuming that freezing first is always harmless or automatically superior.

When is freezing all embryos the better decision?

There are situations where I would actively recommend postponing embryo transfer and freezing suitable embryos.

These include:

  • Significant risk of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS)
  • Premature progesterone elevation, suggesting that embryo and endometrium may no longer be optimally synchronised
  • An endometrial abnormality or uterine pathology that needs investigation or treatment first
  • Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT), where embryos need to be biopsied and results obtained before transfer
  • Circumstances where there is another clinical reason to delay pregnancy
  • Patient preference

The OHSS indication is particularly well established. The American Society for Reproductive Medicine recommends considering a freeze‑only strategy in women at significant risk of OHSS, supported by high‑quality evidence showing that it reduces moderate‑to‑severe OHSS.

So this isn’t an argument against frozen embryo transfer.

It is an argument for using frozen embryo transfer when it provides an advantage to that particular patient.

And if we use a frozen embryo — does the type of frozen cycle matter?

Absolutely.

This is an increasingly important part of the discussion.

A frozen embryo transfer can be performed in several ways. Two common approaches are:

Natural or modified‑natural FET

We work with the woman’s own ovulatory cycle. She develops a follicle, ovulates and forms a corpus luteum, which naturally produces hormones that support early pregnancy.

Programmed or artificial FET

The endometrium is prepared using oestrogen and progesterone medication without relying on spontaneous ovulation.

Programmed cycles are extremely useful and are sometimes necessary. But if a woman ovulates regularly and there is no clinical reason to suppress that physiology, my preference is often to work with her body rather than against it.

Why add medication she may not need?

There may also be another important reason.

The corpus luteum may matter more than we once realised

For years we concentrated primarily on implantation and pregnancy rates when comparing different frozen‑transfer protocols.

Increasing evidence suggests we also need to think about what happens throughout the pregnancy.

A systematic review and meta‑analysis in Human Reproduction found programmed FET cycles were associated with higher rates of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and pre‑eclampsia compared with natural‑cycle FET, although much of this earlier evidence was observational and therefore could not prove causation.

Then came an important randomised trial.

Published in The BMJ in January 2026, the study randomised 4,376 ovulatory women undergoing frozen single‑blastocyst transfer to either a natural ovulation regimen or a programmed hormone regimen.

The healthy live birth rate was essentially the same:

  • 41.6% with natural ovulation
  • 40.6% with programmed treatment

But among women who became pregnant, pre‑eclampsia occurred in 2.9% following the natural regimen, compared with 4.6% following programmed treatment.

The natural group also experienced lower rates of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy, postpartum haemorrhage and several other maternal complications, although natural cycles had a higher cancellation rate.

One possible biological explanation involves the corpus luteum.

The corpus luteum doesn’t simply make progesterone. It produces a number of vasoactive substances involved in the cardiovascular adaptations of early pregnancy. In a completely programmed FET cycle where ovulation does not occur, there is no corpus luteum.

This remains an evolving area of reproductive medicine, and programmed FET remains an appropriate and valuable treatment for many women. More recent research also reminds us that risk is individual and that artificial cycles should not simply be abandoned.

But for an ovulatory woman, it gives us another reason to ask whether medication is actually necessary.

Does this mean natural FET is always better?

No — and this is where fertility medicine becomes individualised.

  • Some women don’t ovulate predictably.
  • Some have very irregular cycles.
  • Some require hormonal preparation for clinical reasons.
  • Some patients find intensive monitoring difficult because of work, travel, distance or family commitments.

And programmed cycles allow far greater control over timing.

Even within natural‑cycle treatment, there are different approaches. A modified‑natural cycle, where ovulation may be triggered rather than simply waiting for a spontaneous LH surge, can provide some scheduling flexibility while preserving the corpus luteum. Available evidence suggests modified‑natural and true‑natural approaches can achieve comparable live birth rates.

The goal isn’t to make one protocol the winner.

The goal is to choose intelligently.

So, fresh or frozen?

My answer remains:

Neither is automatically better.

For some women, freezing embryos is clearly safer and medically preferable.

For others, there may be absolutely no reason not to proceed with a fresh embryo transfer.

And when using a frozen embryo in a woman who ovulates regularly, I think we should also ask whether we can safely work with her natural physiology rather than automatically using a programmed cycle.

IVF has given us extraordinary technology.

But more technology doesn’t necessarily mean that every patient needs more intervention.

Sometimes the most sophisticated decision in fertility treatment is knowing when to use technology — and when not to.

And if anyone asks me whether I personally prefer fresh or frozen?

I really can’t choose.

My two boys came from the same stimulation cycle: one fresh and one frozen. I love them both dearly.

I think I’ll call that one a draw.

Speak with a Melbourne fertility specialist about your embryo transfer

Considering IVF or planning your next embryo transfer?

Dr Kokum Jayasinghe is a fertility specialist in Collingwood, Melbourne. Request an appointment or call 03 9417 3755.

References

  1. Shi Y, Sun Y, Hao C, et al. Transfer of Fresh versus Frozen Embryos in Ovulatory Women. New England Journal of Medicine. 2018;378:126-136.
  2. Stormlund S, Sopa N, Zedeler A, et al. Freeze-all versus fresh blastocyst transfer strategy during in vitro fertilisation in women with regular menstrual cycles: multicentre randomised controlled trial. BMJ. 2020;370:m2519.
  3. Stormlund S, et al. Cumulative live birth rates in a freeze-all or fresh transfer strategy after one ART cycle in ovulatory women. 2024.
  4. Frozen versus fresh embryo transfer in women with low prognosis for in vitro fertilisation treatment: pragmatic, multicentre, randomised controlled trial. BMJ. 2025;388:e081474.
  5. American Society for Reproductive Medicine Practice Committee. Prevention of moderate and severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome: a guideline. 2023.
  6. Busnelli A, et al. Obstetric and perinatal outcomes following programmed compared to natural frozen-thawed embryo transfer cycles: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Human Reproduction. 2022;37:1619-1641.
  7. Wei D, Qin Y, Sun Y, et al. Natural ovulation versus programmed regimens before frozen embryo transfer in ovulatory women: multicentre, randomised clinical trial. BMJ. 2026;392:e087045.
  8. Endometrial preparation protocols for frozen embryo transfer: risk assessment and individualized management. Human Reproduction. 2025;40:1815-1827.
4.9
Based on 158 reviews
Bec profile picture
Bec
6 days ago
Dr Kokum was a blessing for our IVF journey to have children utilising donor sperm. She was knowledgeable, supportive, respectful and successfully assisted both my wife and I on our first IVF cycle to successfully become pregnant. We would not have our beautiful children without her expertise and support.
We would highly recommend Dr Kokum to anyone whom is needing any assistance with their IVF journey especially when other services may not been successful. Dr Kokum is extremely experienced and knowledgeable.
Jade Nursery profile picture
Jade Nursery
7 days ago
We saw Dr Kokum Jayasinghe for a fertility consultation in Melbourne. She was straightforward but warm, and gave us time to ask questions without feeling rushed. We appreciated being able to have an open conversation and leave with a clearer understanding of what had been discussed.
dilini nadeeshani profile picture
dilini nadeeshani
2 weeks ago
Dr. Kokum is truly exceptional. Her kindness, compassion, and professionalism made such a difference throughout my IVF journey. She is caring, patient, and supportive, and always makes you feel heard, understood, and in safe hands. Her dedication and genuine concern for her patients are truly appreciated. I’m so grateful to have had her as my doctor and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for an IVF specialist who combines medical expertise with a warm and compassionate approach. Thank you, Dr. Kokum, for your outstanding care and kindness! ❤️
Susan Fung profile picture
Susan Fung
2 weeks ago
Dr Kokum Jayasinghe is very professional, knowledgeable and compassionate. She took the time to explain each step clearly, answer the questions and make sure the patients felt comfortable with every decision. You never felt rushed and always felt that your concerns were genuinely heard. Highly recommend Dr Jayasinghe for anyone considering IVF.
Anisha profile picture
Anisha
4 weeks ago
I am deeply grateful to Dr Kokum for her outstanding care, professionalism, and support throughout my gynaecological treatment and fertility journey.

From the initial consultation, procedures and ongoing care, she consistently demonstrated kindness, compassion, and patience. Her calm and reassuring manner helped to navigate both the highs and the challenges with confidence and hope.

Thank you, Dr Kokum, for the dedication and genuine care you showed every step of the way. Your support has had a profound impact and I will always be grateful.
Alaa profile picture
Alaa
3 months ago
We had such a positive experience with Dr.Kokum ,for me I never forget our first meeting which was a very beautiful coincidence i was with another doctor at that time but she was on leave that day and we meet Dr. Kokum to do ultrasound for me and in that very moment we felt her warmth and care and we immediately changed our doctor because we felt more comfortable to share this extraordinary journey with her I'm beyond thankful and grateful for you Dr.Kokum because of you our dreams came true and we welcomed 2 angels to our life.
I recommend Dr. Kokum to everyone who's seeking help because this journey is already hard enough for us mothers but if it is dealt with kind ,warmth and compassion success is on higher level.
I really pray for Dr. Kokum and her team to have the strength and faith to help alot of families just like us and make them happy.
David Stojic profile picture
David Stojic
3 months ago
I couldn’t recommend Dr Kokum more highly. Thanks to her expertise, guidance and care, I now have two beautiful, healthy children, and I’m incredibly grateful.
From the beginning, I felt safe, comfortable and genuinely cared for. She was knowledgeable and confident, but also very open and honest about the realities of fertility treatment, which I really appreciated. I always felt like I was in capable hands and could trust her advice.

I’m so happy with where we are today and will always be grateful for the role she played in helping us grow our family. I highly recommend her to anyone on their fertility journey.
pom insurance profile picture
pom insurance
6 months ago
I had a very positive experience with Dr. Kokum. From the beginning, she was caring, professional, and always took the time to explain everything clearly. I always felt like I was in safe hands. She made me feel comfortable and supported throughout my IVF journey. I truly appreciate her dedication, patience, and guidance during such an important time. Highly recommend MIVF to anyone looking for compassionate and knowledgeable fertility care.”
Dilpreet Singh profile picture
Dilpreet Singh
7 months ago
I am extremely grateful to Dr.kokum for helping us achieve a successful IUI treatment. From the very first consultation, the doctor was patient, understanding, and took the time to explain every step of the process clearly. This made us feel comfortable and confident throughout the journey.
The entire experience was handled with great professionalism and care. Dr. Kokum and the team were always supportive, approachable, and responsive to our concerns, which made a big difference during what can be an emotional time.
Thanks to their expertise and guidance, we have received the wonderful news we were hoping for. I truly appreciate the dedication and commitment shown, and I would highly recommend Dr. kokum to anyone seeking fertility treatment.

Thank you once again for making this possible for us.
Danielle Pumpa profile picture
Danielle Pumpa
7 months ago
Dr Kokum has been an exceptional doctor throughout our entire journey. My husband and I were very happy with our whole experience from day one. We had complete confidence in her and fell pregnant after having a transfer and now have a beautiful baby girl.
We would highly recommend Kokum. She was amazing!
Leonie Jenkins profile picture
Leonie Jenkins
7 months ago
We went to see Dr Kokum around this time last year (2025) after we were struggling to fall pregnant after our miscarriage. From the very first appointment she made us feel comfortable and most importantly heard and discussed our options with us thoroughly. She left no stone unturned and guided us through each step of the fertility process and luckily we fell pregnant after the third month of working with her, with our beautiful daughter being born at the beginning of March this year (2026). Without her, I don't think we would be where we are today.
Bonita Swann profile picture
Bonita Swann
7 months ago
We found Dr Kokum through word of mouth, I can happily say that she successfully led us through an IVF process with a very ‘successful outcome’. Dr Kokum is highly professional and calm. We also had really positive interactions with the nurses associated with Dr Kokum. An added bonus is her beautiful new consulting rooms on Wellington St - a tranquil and comfortable space. I would definitely recommend her to family, friends, anyone.
Nkiranji profile picture
Nkiranji
10 months ago
Dr. Kokum is an excellent gynecologist—kind, patient, and deeply understanding. She listens carefully and explains everything clearly, which made me feel comfortable and confident throughout my consultations. I am writing this review almost 1.5 years later, as I got caught up with pregnancy and life after childbirth.
I gave birth to a beautiful baby girl in October 2025. Our journey to parenthood began in 2021. I experienced multiple miscarriages around the 7th week, and despite visiting several doctors, all reports—mine and my husband’s—were completely normal. No one could explain the real cause. Based on one doctor’s advice, I went through two rounds of IVF, which turned out to be a very difficult and unnecessary experience for me, both physically and emotionally, as I was otherwise healthy.
Dr. Kokum came into our lives like an angel. She conducted thorough tests for both me and my husband, patiently explained every result in detail, and clearly guided us on the next steps after reviewing those results. We followed her advice with complete faith. She reassured us that we were healthy and encouraged us to try naturally, with only minimal supportive medication—not because we needed it, but simply for support. Her honesty, clarity, and encouragement meant everything to us.
I still remember her words when I found out I was pregnant again and had already crossed 7 weeks. She told me to let go of the painful past, believe that everything was going well now, and remain stress-free and positive for a successful pregnancy. She was my doctor until 9 weeks, and everything was progressing beautifully. You truly need a doctor in life who encourages you and speaks positively, and I felt that deeply with Dr. Kokum. She was always optimistic, smiling, and even cracked gentle jokes to keep us light-hearted and free from unnecessary stress.
Unfortunately, due to not having private insurance, I couldn’t continue my pregnancy care or deliver under her, and I was transferred to the Royal Women’s Hospital from the 10th week. If I had my way, I would never have left Dr. Kokum throughout my pregnancy.
To all women reading this: please keep your hope of becoming a mother alive, but don’t let the journey consume your entire life. Enjoy living as well. If motherhood is written in your fate, it may come late—but it will come, just like it did for me.
I will always remain deeply grateful to Dr. Kokum for her care, honesty, positivity, and compassion. She truly makes a difference in her patients’ lives.
Sonya Laferla profile picture
Sonya Laferla
10 months ago
My husband and I were very happy with our experience with Dr Kokum and her team.
From the moment we met her we felt cared for, listened to and no request or question ever felt silly or went unanswered. She has a very approachable and kind nature. We felt she was with us every step of the way and her team of nurses are exceptional.
We had complete confidence in her and we are now pregnant with our baby boy!
We would highly recommend Kokum.
Madelyn Iddon profile picture
Madelyn Iddon
11 months ago
My husband and i highly recommend Kokum.
She is incredible at what she does.
The moment we met Kokum she made us both feel so comfortable and that we were in great hands, Which was so important to us.
We’ve been working with her on our journey for nearly 3 years and have lucky enough got a 2 year old daughter and our second on the way. We are forever greatful for all of what Kokum has done for our family.
Thank you Kokum and team.
Love Maddie Tim and Sadie xxx
Saumya D. profile picture
Saumya D.
12 months ago
Dr Kokum has been an exceptional doctor and an extraordinary human being throughout my entire journey. From day one, she treated me with compassion, patience, and genuine care. What I appreciated most was her ability to guide me through important decisions with complete clarity — never rushing, always listening, and making sure I fully understood every option.
Her knowledge is outstanding, and she is incredibly resourceful, always prepared with explanations, alternatives, and thoughtful advice. Despite the complexity of the process, she made everything feel manageable, and her calm, human approach made a huge difference during stressful moments.
I also want to thank her wonderful team, whose kindness and professionalism made every visit smooth and reassuring, as well as the clinic with its state-of-the-art facilities that added so much confidence and comfort along the way.
Thank you, Dr Kokum, for your professionalism, your kindness, and for being the type of doctor who truly stands beside their patients. I feel deeply grateful for your support and would recommend you wholeheartedly to anyone seeking exceptional care.
Siobhan Heneghan profile picture
Siobhan Heneghan
1 year ago
Dr Jayasinghe is incredibly knowledgeable, and I felt reassured throughout the entire process. She took the time to explain every option in detail and helped us understand what to expect at each stage of treatment.
Beyond her expertise, what truly sets Kokum apart is her compassionate approach. She was always so kind, patient, and understanding of the emotional toll this journey can take.
Thanks to her expertise and the tailored treatment plan, we have our beautiful daughter and another on the way. We are beyond grateful for her help.
I highly recommend her to anyone seeking fertility care. Her expertise, compassion, and dedication make all the difference.
See All Reviews